I'd like to understand the impeachment of a respondent in a civil hearing through an example. Let's say you are the respondent in court bec someone claimed you threatened them and are now suing you for, say, emotional distress. You state in court that you never threatened anyone in your life. Then the accuser brings in a witness who testified that you threatened him/her in a different incident a year ago. Since "threatening" is subjective (some may not perceive giving another their 2 cents as threatening, while others may perceive someone with a booming voice and a strong opinion as a threatening), does the witness' testimony impeach the respondent's credibility in this example? Looking for a straightforward answer specific to the example only.
Simon, Eddins & Greenstone, LLP, (SEG Law) is one of the country's most prominent trial law firms specializing in representing victims of cancer caused from exposure to hazardous substances such as asbestos. The firm was built on a shared passion to diligently and compassionately serve each client through every step of the legal process.For more information visit us at SEGlaw.com
1 Answer from Attorneys
Impeachment simply means the offering of evidence to call into question the truth of evidence presented by the other side, either by countering the evidence or calling into question the honesty of the other side's witness or both. It has nothing to do with whether the impeachment evidence is compelling or persuasive or not. It can be completely unpersuasive yet it is still impeachment evidence. So, yes, the situation you describe would be impeachment evidence.
Related Questions & Answers
I have a personal injury case and I truly believe my lawyer is trying to defraud me... Asked 4/03/13, 1:13 pm in United States California Personal Injury Law and Tort Law
I got injured from someone use exercise machine inproperly, I must sue the person,... Asked 4/03/13, 10:41 am in United States California Personal Injury Law and Tort Law
If my civil injury case has been vacated due to a health matter and I haven't heard... Asked 4/02/13, 8:16 am in United States California Personal Injury Law and Tort Law
What is the statue of limitation for a lawsuit against the federal government ? Asked 3/30/13, 11:56 am in United States California Personal Injury Law and Tort Law
Can a company be held liable if an employee gets hurt at sporting event while... Asked 3/21/13, 2:25 pm in United States California Personal Injury Law and Tort Law