Legal Question in Immigration Law in California

My Wife got H1B approved from two different Employers [A&B]. Now we need to decline the h1b from employer "A", and retain with Employer "B". But Employer "A" has asked us to sign a document before applying H1b, which states that if the employee does not join the employer after work visa is approved ,

the employer shall be entitled to injunctive relief and liquidated damages in the amount of USD 5000.

Now, my question is do I need to pay the USD 5000?

We have not start working with any employer yet. Please clarify


Asked on 9/08/13, 6:07 pm

2 Answers from Attorneys

James Brown Brown Law Practice, PLLC

I am somewhat confused by your question. If your wife has not signed the contract with employer A, and she knows that she will be employed by employer B, there is no contract with employer A for employer A to enforce.

If you sign or have signed a contract with employer A which includes a liquidated damages clause, it would probably be enforceable if it is valid under the state law which controls the contract. Whether or not it is enforceable would depend on whether the clause is construed as a liquidated damages clause (permissible) or a penalty (prohibited).

I highly recommend you contact an immigration attorney because the answer to your question depends on many variables, including the way the contract has been drafted, the state law which controls the contract, and other things.

This email is for general information purposes only and does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Read more
Answered on 9/09/13, 7:25 am
Marlene Hemmings Marlene Hemmings, Attorney at Law

As Attorney Brown has stated, if she signed an employment (civil) contract, then the employer might be able to take civil (monetary) action against her. Otherwise, this is unlawful & not an Immigration law question at all.

You should meet with an Employment Law attorney and have him/her review any employment contract that she may have signed with this prospective employer.

In the meantime, she should not sign anything.

Read more
Answered on 9/09/13, 10:40 am


Related Questions & Answers

More Immigration Law questions and answers in California