Legal Question in Real Estate Law in California

I have heard that a neighbor plans to put a gate across a driveway that is a deeded access for almost a dozen other neighbors. What responsibilities does the gate builder have to inform or allow access to all others who are authorized to use that road? Is the person who installs the gate allowed to charge others for costs of the gate?? If there is a key or remote control unit designed to open the gate is the gate builder required to supply these to all the authorized user? (and at whose cost?) If there is a key or access code to open the gate are they required to share this information with emergency responders? (Fire and Rescue, Law Enforcement, Ambulance?) What about utility service people such as meter readers, power pole maintenance, package delivery, etc.? It could be helpful to discourage salespeople, door-to-door evangelists and other solicitors and trick-or-treaters.


Asked on 4/16/16, 1:34 pm

1 Answer from Attorneys

Bryan Whipple Bryan R. R. Whipple, Attorney at Law

The installation of gates, particularly locked gates (even if the users are furnished keys or the combination), across an easement has been examined critically by the courts, and with mixed results. The courts have generally held that a landowner cannot install a gate across a roadway used by others under a written or implied easement agreement unless the landowner has a valid and rather strong need for the gate, such as keeping in his cattle, or where trespassers or vandals present a genuine problem, since installing a gate without some justification is an unfair burden upon the easement holders and their guests. I think if your situation were to go to court, the judge would weigh the justification for having a gate against the burden it would place on the easement holders, and the ultimate outcome would depend upon a great many facts present in your particular situation. However, as a general rule, if the driveway here is lawfully used by a dozen neighbors with valid easement rights, I think the installation of a gate, especially a locked gate, would go too far in impairing the easement holders' rights and a court would not allow it.

Read more
Answered on 4/16/16, 1:55 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Real Estate and Real Property questions and answers in California