Legal Question in Military Law in Colorado

Accused of Rape

My roommate was accused of rape. After OSI investigated they told his lawyer that there is little or no evidence proving her story (eye witnesses saw her all over him all night, rape kit negative, ect....) Well they want him to do a polygraph test to keep it from going to court martial and ending the investigate. I don't think he should cause they don't have any evidence but should he?


Asked on 2/19/09, 5:34 pm

3 Answers from Attorneys

William J. Holmes Attorney at Military Law

Re: Accused of Rape

I would be very careful about taking a polygraph. First of all, they are not admissible at trial. Thus, they are usually used as a means of questioning the suspect and trying to get him to say somthing which the can use against him. If they do not have any evidence against him, he should make sure not to say anything or to give them anything which they could use. Normally, I do not allow my clients to take a polygraph like that. However, there may be some exceptions if they are willing to drop the charges. If necessry, I would suggest that he take a private polygraph set up by his lawyer. If he passes it, that fact can be given to the prosecutors. If he does not pass, do not reveal anything and everything should be covered by the attorney client priviledge. Be careful and have him closely consult with his attorney about whether to take such a test or not.

I hope this has helped. Please feel free to contact me directly if you have any further questions.

Read more
Answered on 2/20/09, 1:48 pm
Philip D. Cave Military Law & Justice

Re: Accused of Rape

I would beware polygraphs.

In my experience they are often used as an interrogation tool. I never recommend a polygraph unless it's arranged and set up through the defense counsel.

It's ALWAYS better for them not to have a statement from him. Even though he might deny involvement, I've seen them take and twist something said to harm the client.

Generally not a good idea at this time. There are too many issues, and I do MANY of these types of cases for him to put anything in writing or oral at this time.

Later, if there's some move to prosecute, then there are alternatives.

Read more
Answered on 2/19/09, 5:39 pm
Anthony DeWitt Bartimus, Frickleton Robertson & Gorny, PC

Re: Accused of Rape

If your friend has a lawyer, he should listen to that lawyer and take his lawyer's advice. If I were advising you in this situation, I would tell you not to take it. It is usually a ploy by the investigators to get incriminating statements.

Read more
Answered on 2/19/09, 5:45 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Military Law questions and answers in Colorado