My ex fiance moved out in 2011. He is now asking for property that he had not asked for since 2011 and is threatening to sue me if I don't give it to him. It was a purchase he made during the course of our relationship but an item I used personally. Can he sue me for the saddle if I have used it and had possession of it since he moved out?
1 Answer from Attorneys
If it was his but he allowed you to use it, it's still his. If he bought it as a gift for you, gave it to you and you used it, then it's a done deal, but you'd have to prove it was a gift. The fact that he's waited this long to ask for it back MAY be some evidence that it was a gift and now he's trying to reneg.I know saddles can cost a lot of money; you can decide what will give you the least grief.
Related Questions & Answers
I am going through a divorce and in the marriage settlement package it states,... Asked 4/08/13, 9:32 am in United States Illinois Civil Rights Law
My question is the police came to my house busted my door open with a iron... Asked 4/07/13, 2:05 pm in United States Illinois Civil Rights Law
I was a little league football coach this past year. I was not retained as a coach... Asked 3/22/13, 12:49 pm in United States Illinois Civil Rights Law
I am being sued in federal court along with a number of co-defendants. I just found... Asked 3/18/13, 4:45 pm in United States Illinois Civil Rights Law
My daughter is going to live with my mother due to finacial difficulties. The school... Asked 3/17/13, 2:46 pm in United States Illinois Civil Rights Law