Legal Question in Workers Comp in Massachusetts

knee injury

I have been working as a auto mechanic for the last 25 years. In the course of my work I kneel on the concrete floor, and move around on my knees to set the lifts to lift the cars. After many years of doing this, I feel this is the reason for my injury. The injury is, when I bend my left knee,and apply pressure to that side, I feel the bone shift causing much pain. The only way to pop the bone back in is to extend the leg at a straight angle. My concern is will they see this as a legitimate claim. Please respond at E Mail address below. THANK YOU


Asked on 5/06/07, 11:54 pm

1 Answer from Attorneys

Craig J. Tiedemann Kajko, Weisman & Colasanti, LLP

Re: knee injury

As someone who has had 7 knee surgeries, two of which were major joint reconstructions, I can tell you with reasonable confidence that you have torn meniscus, a/k/a torn cartilege (this is my lay opinion, not legal advice or a medical opinion). Given the deteriorating condition of my knoee, I constantly develop the painful condition you describe, which feels like a painful snap or pop, causing greeat pain, especially when bearing weight.

A routine arthroscopic procedure (knee scope) can probably fix it and reduce or eliminate the symptoms altogether.

The longer you leave it untreated, the worse it will get, as the knee releases fluid in response to the tear, and over time the fluid eats away at and kills off additional cartilege, which leads to more fluid, etc, and the condition snowballs upon itself.

Knee scopes are 45 minute procedures, done as an outpatient day surgery. You can be back on your feet within a few days, back to work within a week or so. See an orthopedist.

Because knee cartilege also deteriorates with wear and tear and naturally as we age, I don't think you have a claim against your employer for causing the condition. That depends, however, on your specific circumstances. Go see the ortho and let him tell you what he thinks.

This is NOT legal advice or a medical opinion. Just words from a fellow knee pain sufferer.

Read more
Answered on 5/07/07, 11:30 am


Related Questions & Answers

More Workers' Compensation Law questions and answers in Massachusetts