Legal Question in Landlord & Tenant Law in Minnesota

I moved out of my town home a month ago after living there for two years. I just got a bill from the landlord for $5000 that already includes the subtraction of a $1900 security deposit for the replacement of the carpet. I admit that the carpet was shot, I have a small dog that refuses to be potty trained, so I was prepared for the fact that the carpet would need to be replaced.

My question is, the previous carpet was installed in 2006 so its over 8 years old at the time of it being replaced. Am I responsible for the full cost of the new carpet or is there a depreciating value? and should I pay the replacment cost of the new carpet or the cost of the carpet that was there previously? I have not been supplied with any documentation showing the quality and cost of the previous carpet, only the bill for the new stuff that is mid-high grade including a memory foam pad.


Asked on 6/24/14, 1:38 pm

2 Answers from Attorneys

David Anderson Anderson Business Law LLC

Key issue is:

What is reasonable wear & tear?

If pets were allowed, then it would include reasonable wear & tear WITH PETS

Call me if you wish to contest

I have 33 years experience as a MN landlord & representing LLs & tenants

Read more
Answered on 6/24/14, 2:02 pm
Morgan Kavanaugh Wilkerson & Hegna, PLLP

You are not liable for the full cost of the new carpet. Perhaps that carpet had no value left and you have a defense if they come after you for the $5,000. You also may have a claim to recover your security deposit of $1,900.

Read more
Answered on 6/24/14, 2:06 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Landlord & Tenants questions and answers in Minnesota