Coercion and Civil Rights
Under what circumstances can the government coerce a person into sacrificing his/her constitutionally protected Civil Liberties? In a previous answer (http://www.lawguru.com/cgi/bbs/mesg.cgi?i=297387631), it was suggested that the government may (and they do) require a person to sacrifice certain liberties as a condition of using the airlines. Would the same logic allow the government to require that individuals refrain from criticizing the government or voting in federal elections as a condition of holding a drivers license (a privilege)?
1 Answer from Attorneys
Re: Coercion and Civil Rights
No. The government can only restrict First Amendment rights in order to meet a compelling state interest and even then must do so by the least restrictive means possible. There is no connection at all between driving and political speech, so the type of restriction you describe would be unjustifiable. There is, however, a very strong connection between carrying concealed items through airport security on the one hand and airline bombings and hijackings on the other. The two situations you describe are not morally equivalent.
Related Questions & Answers
Patriot Act & T.S.A. Search & Seizure In response to a previous question... Asked 10/23/06, 2:55 pm in United States New Hampshire Constitutional Law
What are the checks and balances among the branches of government? I am a graudate... Asked 1/14/06, 2:53 pm in United States New Hampshire Constitutional Law
Application to carry a pistol I have a question about the pistol/revolver license... Asked 1/14/06, 10:21 am in United States New Hampshire Constitutional Law
Can testimony from a civil case be used in a criminal case? If someone were to make... Asked 1/18/05, 7:56 pm in United States New Hampshire Constitutional Law
Probable Cause? Last month my home alarm system went off one evening at 2:00AM. When... Asked 11/21/04, 8:28 am in United States New Hampshire Constitutional Law