Legal Question in Insurance Law in North Carolina

Personal injury in a motor vehicle accident

I was involved in a motor vehicle accident, the woman driving had hit me head on at a rate of 70mph. She died instantly at the scene. The truck she was driving at the time she had borrowed. Both of my heels were crushed, I had severe brain damage, I was in a coma on life support, I have lost a son to his father, I've had 2 surgeries so far and am expecting 3 more, I have very little use of my legs. Is the owner of the truck in any way responsible?


Asked on 7/11/02, 8:19 pm

1 Answer from Attorneys

John Kirby Law Offices of John M. Kirby

Re: Personal injury in a motor vehicle accident

Wow. That raises a lot of questions. As to whether the owner is responsible "maybe." Under North Carolina law, there is a "presumption" that the driver was acting as an agent for the Owner, but this is "rebuttable." As a practical matter, you could always have this ultimately decided by a jury. Also, if the owner was "negligent" in entrusting the vehicle to the driver, then the Owner is independently negligent and is liable (e.g. if the driver was a habitually bad driver). Finally, I should mention that your more pressing concern is where you can recover funds from. At the outset, you can recover from the Driver's Liability Insurance, the Owner's Liability Insurance (even if the Owner is not liable!), and your own "underinsured motorist" coverage, depending on the coverages and your damages. Your only real reason to be able to sue the owner is if the insurance money is not enough AND there would be funds to collect from the Owner. You really need a lawyer with that degree of injuries to preserve your claim and maximize your recovery and to explore the insurance coverage available.

Read more
Answered on 7/12/02, 2:14 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Insurance Law questions and answers in North Carolina