In the U.S what conviction and defense would most likely be given to a person that had been kidnapped and forced to kill in a fighting ring?
The person had to kill or be killed.
1 Answer from Attorneys
If it reasonably appeared that the other person in the ring would imminently kill him or cause great bodily injury, then the defendant would have been acting in self-defense and would be entitled to an acquittal. If not, then he would be guilty of murder -- perhaps even in the first degree -- or at least manslaughter.
Self-defense is only allowed against the person who is threatening you. It does not allow you to kill one person in order to avoid a threat from another. There are many crimes the law would excuse under the circumstances you describe, but homicide is not one of them.
Related Questions & Answers
I didn't finish my community service in the time allowed and was arrested . I;ve... Asked 8/02/12, 11:32 am in United States Oregon Criminal Law
I lied to police officers by telling them the man I've been with for over a year... Asked 7/22/12, 3:55 pm in United States Oregon Criminal Law
I am on bench probation for a class a misdemeanor, I just got a mip yesterday what... Asked 7/14/12, 4:11 pm in United States Oregon Criminal Law