I own a business that buys,sells and trades new and used equipment. I purchased a bike in good faith from a customer that bought the bike from a bike shop with a bad check and the sold it to us. I turned around and sold it to a customer. Afetr 6 months the bike needed to be repaired and the customer happened to take it to the bike shop where it was purchased with the bad check, the bike shop called the police and the police took it off of the customer and returned it to the bike shop. I have talked to 2 different lawyers and they said that it is the property of my customer and that the police messed up and that the bike shop should have to go after the person that passed the bad check, and my customer should get the bike back. I feel bad about the whole thing but am I liable to give the customer his money back.
1 Answer from Attorneys
As a Franchise Attorney I can only ask: why are you posting this question if you've talked to two different lawyers? And, if property is reported stolen, and the police recover it, they will return it to whoever is able to prove legal ownership - which appears to be the bike shop that sold it originally. They're not going to get involved in a civil matter involving bad checks, etc. That's for others in the chain of events to deal with and sort out. Consult with a good business or franchise attorney in your area for specific advice.
Mr. Franchise - Kevin B. Murphy, B.S., M.B.A., J.D.
Franchise Foundations, a Professional Corporation
Related Questions & Answers
I am planning to start up an online tutoring business. We are planning to get the... Asked 5/21/11, 7:11 am in United States Pennsylvania Business Law
A business was sold and the shareholders were making monthly payments. For the past... Asked 5/17/11, 7:46 pm in United States Pennsylvania Business Law
When two people borrow money with a promissary note and the note is not being paid... Asked 5/12/11, 7:29 pm in United States Pennsylvania Business Law
Hi, I'm starting a video game development company and am having trouble finding... Asked 4/30/11, 10:22 am in United States Pennsylvania Business Law
If a company provides services online or offline do they have to provide customer... Asked 4/25/11, 7:28 pm in United States Pennsylvania Business Law