This is for my criminal law class. Say someome attempts to murder. The victim lives but is on life support and in a coma. Question: If the person is brain dead is it actual murder or still attempted murder? If the person dies while in treatment is it still murder and is there a time limit on this. If the family chooses to pull life support is it murder or attempted?
1 Answer from Attorneys
Once the person expires, it's murder, and if the victim dies during the course of treatment or is brain-dead and the family authorizes the "pulling of the plug", so to speak, it's still murder for the alleged perpetrator.
Why so, i.e., the legal rationale? One must be held to account for the natural consequences of one's actions, a legal proposition which must necessarily apply to this hypothetical scenario.
Related Questions & Answers
20 year old male with under age girl what are the consequences of a 20 year old male... Asked 8/12/07, 3:29 am in United States Virginia Criminal Law
Showcause capius I was on probation from a charge in 1995. I had a suspended 10 year... Asked 8/11/07, 12:34 pm in United States Virginia Criminal Law
Board of Nursing application In 1976 I was charged w/ intent to distribute MJ and... Asked 8/10/07, 10:04 am in United States Virginia Criminal Law
Perjury Hi, I recently put my fiance in jail for assault and battery stating that he... Asked 8/10/07, 9:21 am in United States Virginia Criminal Law
Maximum penalty underage pocession of alcohol A 19 year old female friend has just... Asked 8/10/07, 5:04 am in United States Virginia Criminal Law