Legal Question in Business Law in California

contract breach NY & CA

I and a number of individuals from a couple of different states (NY, MA) each separately 'invested' in a product pitched to us about four years ago. This product included DVD's, and printed materials, had a specific title, and was to be advertised nationally and internationally as an infomercial, at seminars, and through a website promotion, starting at contract signing. Signed contracts stated we would be paid a certain percentage for each item sold, payment to be recieved with propper accounting documentaion of sales, every two months from inception. The contract has now been breached in the following ways. 1) The infomercial has never run 2) The few seminars held have ceased 3) We were only paid for a few sales, checks and paper work stopped and hasn't come for over two years 4) A year after contact signing, the owner/promoter of the LLC in CA has since taken the basic package product, converted it into a book, slightly altered the title, recruited new investors for it, and is currently recruiting new investors for further permutations of the original product only promoting the most recent package.

What mechanisms are available to legally get our money back ( between $3,000 and $25,000 per person investment )?


Asked on 11/12/07, 6:02 pm

1 Answer from Attorneys

Bryan Whipple Bryan R. R. Whipple, Attorney at Law

Re: contract breach NY & CA

The first thing that would be useful to know in more detail is what was actually being sold....you say you invested in 'a product,' but I'm sure what you were actually to receive in exchange for your investment was not a crate-full of DVDs and printed materials; more likely, what you were supposed to get was something in the nature of a security: stock, a membership interest in the LLC, a franchise, units of participation, an investment contract, or something of that ilk. This may be important, because you may be able to bring the sales effort under the securities laws. However, it is very likely that the statute of limitations for a civil action under federal securities law has run out.

In California, however, many securities law violations can be sued upon in a civil action brought within five years (Corporations Code section 25506(b)). With more details, I could evaluate whether this is an availing provision of law in your case.

A breach of contract action based on a written agreement can also be brought (in California, at least) within four years of the date of a breach that is sufficiently serious to give rise to a cause of action for breach of contract.

Before bringing suit, an attorney should first determine proper jurisdiction, then (1) review the contract to identify all the breaches, whether there are attorney-fee or arbitration clauses, and the exact identity of the prospective defendant(s), and (2) research the status of the defendant(s) to see if they have been dissolved or put in bankruptcy, etc.; i.e., whether there is any money reachable by judgment. lot of these scamsters are guardhouse lawyers and know how to recycle their scams without being in jeopardy for their prior offenses.

Read more
Answered on 11/12/07, 7:54 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Business Law questions and answers in California