Legal Question in Construction Law in California

Mechanics Lien

I'm trying to collect the balance due of $4500 for remodeling work. A small piece of granite was not done properly and I offered the consumer the option of my giving him some additional granite at no additional cost and to add a piece of granite to the area in dispute in lieu of replacing the whole piece. He agreed orally to me and the granite fabricator. I believed he was a man of his word so we proceeded to complete the work. Now he refuses to pay saying he doesn't like the added piece. I also represented one of the other general contractors as a designer/sales person but our contracts are separate and distinct. Yet he wants to hold me responsible for their work. I have tried to settle this by presenting him with several other options including offering to replace the whole piece of granite if he makes a partial payment and pays me for the ''no additional cost'' granite. I will not do anymore work as I don't believe he will pay even if I do the work he originally agreed I didn't have to do. I am about to place a mechanics lien on the property, however is there another way to collect what is due me?


Asked on 10/10/04, 6:57 pm

1 Answer from Attorneys

Gary Redenbacher Redenbacher & Brown, LLP

Re: Mechanics Lien

This is a favored technique of not so honest homeowners: refuse to make the final payment. The mechanics lien will sometimes have the effect of forcing an owner to pay without having to "foreclose" the lien. More often than not, however, they simply continue to refuse to pay and start threatening lawsuit of their own. Foreclosing means bringing a lawsuit. You can foreclose a lien in small claims court (up to $5000) although some small claims judges will be confused by your request to foreclose a lien. Generally, they simply hand out money judgments.

You can try to either arbitrate or mediate the dispute. These two techniques are often quicker than lawsuits if the dispute exceeds $5000. Small claims court is very quick and very easy to do. I suggest buying a guide to small claims court from Nolo Press. (www.nolo.com)

You have confused me with your phrase, "one of the other general contractors." There is usually only one general contractor. Sometimes an owner will contract directly with many subs. Perhaps this is what you meant? It is true, however, that as an employee of another contractor, you shouldn't be directly responsible to the owner for problems created by that contractor. You may have to answer to your employer for a mistake you made as a salesman, but the owner usually will have no direct cause of action against you as an employee.

Read more
Answered on 10/10/04, 11:22 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Construction Law questions and answers in California