what is consciousness of guilt?
What is "consciouness of guilt"? I have never heard of it or been able to find it a the law books.
1 Answer from Attorneys
Consciousness of Guilt
When a person who is accused of a crime does something which an innocent person would not do, at least in theory, the law deems that he has displayed a consciousness of guilt. The jury is told that they may weigh such an act as being consciousness of guilt in their deliberations. An example may illustrate the point, and some problems attendant to it. A fight occurs between two men. Someone yells that the police are on their way. One man waits for the police. The other man runs away. Assume that the second man is charged with assault. The issue is what weight is to be attached to the flight by the accused when he learned that the police were coming. The jury will be told that such flight may (emphasis on the word "may") be evidence of consciousness of guilt. Now, the problem is that the accused may have had many unrelated reasons for running. He may have had traffic warrants outstanding. He may have been wanted on more serious charges. It is not a happy choice to consider having to tell the jury in this case about the defendant's problems in other cases just to disarm the consciousness of guilt theory. On the other hand, it is logical that, where unexplained, flight from a crime scene very well may illustrate the accused's own mental state that he had committed a crime. In a sense, the act of running places a burden on the accused to explain such conduct or face the consequences of it.
Related Questions & Answers
Search of vehicle for a narcotics arrest When are the police officially allowed to... Asked 10/20/97, 2:11 am in United States California Criminal Law
Arrested for suspicion of intoxication Working in Ca with government, from Wa.... Asked 10/15/97, 4:13 pm in United States California Criminal Law
My mom has been framed for hitting a little girl!!!! Help!!!! My mom works at a... Asked 10/10/97, 11:36 pm in United States California Criminal Law
Consciousness of guilt? If I went to the police for help because I was afraid for... Asked 10/04/97, 2:34 am in United States California Criminal Law
Prosecutor immunity Should a prosecutor have absolute or qualified immunity in... Asked 9/29/97, 5:46 pm in United States California Criminal Law