Legal Question in Civil Litigation in California

My Situation is this: I owned a home from may 2005 to march 2008 in September 2008 some fell and injured themselves on the sidewalk in front of the house due to the sidewalk being raised by a tree root. The person is suing the city and the city is claiming that the tree was not an approved tree and was not planted by the city so the city is not responsible. So now the injured person is suing the city and the current home owners which will state that the tree was pre existing because the tree was pre existing when I purchased the home in 2005. Now I am being told by the current owners Ins Company that I will likely be sued myself. So my question is: Am I Screwed?


Asked on 10/20/09, 7:46 pm

2 Answers from Attorneys

Mark Saltzman, MBA, JD Law Offices of Mark E. Saltzman

You should be just fine. Two issues are central:

1. The owner of the premises is responsible for making it safe. You are not the owner. End of story, as to the injured party.

2. If you are sued, submit a claim to your homeowners insurance companies...both...your current carrier (for your current home) and the carrier for your previous home. You will likely find coverage at one or both.

Another issue that could arise, but you did not mention is whether you failed to disclose a defect (the tree) that you knew about, when you sold the house. The current owner may have an action against you, based on a failure to disclose, in the Transfer Disclosure Statement that you signed, at the time of sale.

Any real estate attorney could look through the records and help you out.

Good luck.

Read more
Answered on 10/20/09, 7:53 pm
Melvin C. Belli The Belli Law Firm

Not yet! However if there is a problem give it to your insurance company. Of course you might want to suggest to the current homeowners insurance that you warned about this tree being "non conforming" or that they should have clearly seen that it was. Or perhaps you could suggest that it was their fault because they could plainly see the hazard and yet choose to do nothing about it. I'd wait until you get served with a lawsuit before you panic.

I would go to a plaintiff�s personal injury attorney and pay them a fee to consult with them ( which is a novelty because we mostly work on a contingent or percentage fee basis) after all they are in the business of suing people and probably know the law in this area better than a real estate lawyer.

Read more
Answered on 10/21/09, 12:23 am


Related Questions & Answers

More General Civil Litigation questions and answers in California