Legal Question in Insurance Law in California

Act of God or negligence?

While parked at my apt. building during a very windy day recently, a ''roof access panel,'' a 24'' X 24'' sheet metal panel that covers the porch roof access area was blown off the apt. complex and hit my car, causing about $1,400 - $1,900 in damages. Clearly, the access panel was not secured--name removed--the two hooks on the panel. The complex management co., and their insurer are trying to avoid my repair costs, (and rental car use while in the shop) claiming the wind was ''an act of God.''

I claim negligence that the panel was not properly secured.

Do I have a case?


Asked on 4/13/09, 5:11 pm

2 Answers from Attorneys

Steven Murray Steven W. Murray, APC

Re: Act of God or negligence?

If you can prove what you believe happened, you have a case. If not, then the defendant won't be liable and the insurer will have successfully defensed the case.

Did you claim the loss from your own car insurer under your comprehensive coverage?

Read more
Answered on 4/13/09, 9:18 pm
Russell Kohn Kohn Law Office

Re: Act of God or negligence?

The small claims court is known as a "court of equity". This means that the commissioner/judge can decide a case based on what would be an equitable result despite the lack of law or evidence to support such a result. The question is then, who should bear the expense, the innocent car owner or the owner of the sheet metal that got loose and damaged the car? Seems clear to me, but one can never guarantee anything in small claims court.

As for the law in CA, the doctrine of "Res Ipsa Loquitur" (meaning "the thing speaks for itself") shifts the burden of proof to the defendant to show defendant's lack of negligence. Res Ipsa Loquitur applies to those situations where the defendant has control over the object, and is better able to bring forward evidence as to what happened, and where ordinarily such an event does not occur absent negligence. In my personal opinion, sheet metal normally doesn't fall from roofs absent negligence). I don't believe the "act of god" defense would fly (no pun intended). Good luck.

Read more
Answered on 4/13/09, 9:33 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Insurance Law questions and answers in California