Legal Question in Personal Injury in California

Acceptable settlement?

My car was rearended in a left hand turn lane. The at fault party was going about 45 mph. Her car was totalled, my car received little damage, but I sustained significant neck and back injuries. No surgery was necessary, I didn't have a concussion, but needed to see my chiropractor for 4 months totally 3,000 in medical. I also was terrified to drive and had/have anxiety about driving. Her insurance company paid for the damages to my car, and are offering to pay my medical, my lost work wages totally 1,100, and around 2,500 for pain and suffering. Is this an acceptable amount for pain and suffereing?

Several people, including a lawyer friend say I should ask for more due to possible future chiropractic appointments, and the low level constant pain when I'm sitting and driving. How does one calculate the pain and suffering?

Thank you!


Asked on 8/22/04, 8:56 pm

5 Answers from Attorneys

Barry Snyder Snyder Law

Re: Acceptable settlement?

You are without fault in this accident and that is helpful in determining the value of your claim. However, we do not know the name of the insurance company and some are more difficult than others. Assuming it is not one of the more difficult companies to deal with, you should get 100% of your lost wages with good verification from your employer, even if you had to use sick time or comp time. For $3000 in chiropractic treatment, it is true that years ago the rule was "3 times the medicals." Most companies have gone away from that and look at the type of treatment (examinations versus actual treatment) to see if you were really in pain or just having someone look you over. The more actual treatment and less examinations or x-rays, the higher the value of your "pain and suffering." Know that the company is just beginning negotiations and will pay more than their first offer. So, I recommend that you start high, say $12,000, pointing out the significant collison, no fault on your part, and see what they say. If you eventually have to hire an attorney, make sure that their fee is based only on what amount they can get you OVER what the insurance company last offered you. The attorney should not share in what you have negotiated yourself.

Read more
Answered on 8/23/04, 8:16 pm
Amy Ghosh Law Offices of Amy Ghosh

Re: Acceptable settlement?

Three times of your medical bills plust lost wages.

Read more
Answered on 8/23/04, 11:25 pm
Benjamin Berger Berger-Harrison, A Professional Corporation

Re: Acceptable settlement?

There is no real way to calculate pain and suffering. There's no logic to it. What is the value of getting punched in the face? What is the value of having neck pain? Who knows? When one person causes another to suffer, we try to make the injured party whole again and there's no science to calculating the amount. It would eventually come down to a jury deciding how much money it would take to imrove a person's life in an amount equal to the amount of discomfort the person experienced by way of pain and suffering. Sound like muck? It is.

However, as time went by, some of the world began to decide that three times a person's medical bills was a decent measure of pain and suffering. That number was easy to get years ago, now insurance companies are less likely to offer that much.

They've offered you less than one times your meds. That's a typical first offer and you should be able to get more. You'll probably get more if you have a lawyer, even after you pay him a cut of the recovery.

Best of luck.

Read more
Answered on 8/23/04, 4:13 pm
Terry A. Nelson Nelson & Lawless

Re: Acceptable settlement?

One pulls numbers out of thin air, just like the insurance company did. Every case if different and based on the facts. If YOU don't think it is enough, then it should be negotiated higher. That is what your attorney is for.

Read more
Answered on 8/23/04, 4:20 pm
A. Russell Martin Law Office of A. Russell Martin

Re: Acceptable settlement?

Hi,

Sorry you were hurt! Unfortunately, there is no formulaic answer to your question. Personal injury damages are dependent on many case specific factors, so I will need a lot more information to help you determine a fair settlement. Moreover, the insurers will probably victimize you a second time if you try to litigate this yourself. Sadly, that happens all the time. You need our strong litigation team to help you get the money you deserve. Call me at your earliest convenience.

Have a great day and God Bless!

Russ

A. Russell Martin, Esq. (SBN 226244)

MARTIN & McPHERSON

Attorneys at Law

3925 Spring Hill Road

Petaluma, CA 94952

Phone: (415)364-1604

E-Mail: [email protected]

_________________________________________________

DISCLAIMER: MARTIN & McPHERSON, Attorneys at Law, (hereinafter �Attorneys�) are responding to your internet solicitation for legal help. If you did not solicit our help, please delete this e-mail and immediately contact our office to advise that you do not want further communication. This reply does not constitute legal advice. Attorneys cannot render a considered legal opinion based on the limited information provided, so you should not rely on the general legal information contained herein, which may or may not be applicable to your case. Attorneys cannot guarantee a particular result for your case and nothing in this e-mail constitutes a representation regarding the merits of your potential claims. Moreover, this reply is not an offer for professional services. Attorneys will not take any action on your matter and no professional relationship will exist until Attorneys and all prospective clients sign a separate written fee contract according to subsequently negotiated terms. Please be further advised that the law imposes strict time limitations for filing civil actions (�statutes of limitations�). Statutes of limitations are often very short and all potential claims will be lost forever if you fail to file them with the court or appropriate administrative agency in a timely manner. Consequently, you should immediately contact Attorneys or another lawyer to fully protect your legal rights.

A. Russell Martin, Esq. (SBN 226244)

MARTIN & McPHERSON

Attorneys at Law

3925 Spring Hill Road

Petaluma, CA 94952

Phone: (415)364-1604

E-Mail: [email protected]

Read more
Answered on 8/23/04, 4:37 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Personal Injury Law and Tort Law questions and answers in California