Legal Question in Construction Law in Florida

Mechanics liens

I am building a new home, the builder does not do the lot prep, A company who was recommended by a representative of the builder did the lot prep. That company did not give me a detail estimate on the work preformed, over charged me, did a poor quality job and I could not find a license for the lot prep company in the county where the house is being built. I did not pay them. That comapny is now placing a mechanics lien on my property and the builder is now threatening to stop constructing my house if I do not pay the lot prep company. I also do not have a signed contract with the lot prep comapny. What are my options at this point. Also what happens if the lot prep company places a lien on my property? If they do place a lien against my property how do I fight it and get the lien removed?


Asked on 7/28/04, 5:06 pm

2 Answers from Attorneys

Frank Reilly Reilly Roche LLP

Re: Mechanics liens

Seems like Mr. Gilbert already addressed some of the lien and licensing issues. However, you may also want to consider a few issues regarding potentially defective work.

On May 27, 2003, Governor Bush signed into law a new procedure that must be followed prior to the filing of a construction defects lawsuit. Florida Statute Section 558 applies to residential construction (including condos) and only requires notice of defects involving defective materials, violation of applicable building codes, design malpractice, or failure to employ workmanlike construction methods.

The new procedure goes as follows:

60 days before the owner can file a lawsuit, he/she must serve a written �notice of claim� on the construction professional.

The construction professional then has the right to inspect the alleged defect within 5 days.

The construction professional must serve a copy of the �notice of claim� to any other construction professional who he thinks may be responsible for the alleged construction defect within 10 days. (This other construction professional also has the right to inspect).

The construction professional must respond with a written offer to remedy the claim, a written offer of settlement or a written dispute of claim.

The claimant has 15 days to accept or reject the offer. However, if the claimant is an association, the time frame to accept or reject the offer is 45 days.

The claimant can file a lawsuit without further notice if he/she rejects the offer.

The claimant can file a lawsuit without further notice if the construction professional rejects the claim.

The claimant can file a lawsuit without further notice if the construction professional fails to meet the agreed timetable to remedy or settle the claim.

Please be mindful that the new procedure must be strictly followed. This includes properly making, rejecting or accepting offers. It may be in your best interest to contact an experienced attorney who can help you meet your legal requirements without giving away your legal rights.

For more information, please feel free to call us at (954) 229-1008.

Best of luck to you.

Read more
Answered on 7/29/04, 1:01 pm
Randall Gilbert Gilbert & Caddy P.A.

Re: Mechanics liens

You have a lot of questions which can all be answered, but I need additional information to determine whether the "lot prep" company even has the right to lien. For instance (1) did they serve a notice to owner on you and the contractor; (2) who hired the "lot prep" company; (3) what did the "lot prep" comapny do; (4) Does the county where the project is located even require that the "lot prep" company have a license to perform the work it performed; (5) when was the last date that it furnished any work, sevice, labor, or material to the project; (6) why are you refusing to pay - are you disputing the whole bill or just a portion.....

Randall Gilbert

Read more
Answered on 7/28/04, 5:46 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Construction Law questions and answers in Florida