Legal Question in Criminal Law in New York

I am curently on parole after spending 8yrs & 6 months in prison on a burglary in the first degree. I was sentenced to a Determinate sentence of 10yrs. Upon my release i was informed that 5yrs of Post-Release-Supervision was added to my sentence by the Departmnt of Corrections.

After going over my Sentencing Minutes and Commitment order, I found that 5yrs of Post-Release-Supervion was never imposed by the judge, nor was it part of the plea agreement that was reached in my case. The minutes and commitment order clear show this to be the case.

I was able to find some info regarding my issue through prisoners legal services PRO Se pamplets,inwich i found that, this very same issue is shared by alot of parolies and ther is even a class action suit in against the DOC for adding PRS to sentences without a judges order. Also i read that: On June 30,2008, new laws pertaining to determinate sentences and post-release supervision became effective.

My questions to you is ,How can i have the PRS taken of my sentenc? What procedures must i follow in order to remedy this issue? Are there any standard forms to address the courts regarding an issue of this type? and exactly what administrations or courts must i address for this issue?

I would like to thank you in advance for any help and research you would do in answereing these questions. I would also like to let you know in case in matters that i already informed my parole officer of this issue and handed them copys of all relevent paper work, but was ofered no help from them . So please again let me thank you for your time and help


Asked on 5/19/10, 4:02 am

1 Answer from Attorneys

Christopher Brocato Brocato & Byrne, LLP

Only the court that sentenced you has the power to make parole a condition of your sentence. The Department of Correction does not have the authority to added parole to a defendant�s sentence. Currently, Burglary in the First Degree carries mandatory period of parole supervision of five years. However, this was not always the case and depending on when you where convicted, parole supervision might not have been mandatory. I believe that mandatory parole supervision was added on August 6, 1998. The issue becomes were you convicted before August 6, 1998 or after. If you were convicted prior to said date then the Department of Corrections clearly had no authority to alter your sentence. If you were convicted on or after August 6, 1998, then the issues becomes did you enter a plea or were you convicted after trial? If you took a plea with the understanding that the court was not going to impose parole then you have grounds to appeal the imposition of supervised release (parole). This is based on a contract theory, simply that, you negotiated the terms of your sentenced and if you had known that parole was part of the deal you might not have agreed to the plea. I am not so sure you can appeal if you were convicted after a trial on reasoning that you did not have a negotiated bargained for the sentence. Either way you need to have the matter brought back before the court and for that I think you are going to need an attorney. DISCLAIMER: This answer to a short question is provided solely for general informational purposes and based on general legal principles and court practice. This answer does NOT constitute legal advice, create an attorney-client relationship, or constitute attorney advertising.

Read more
Answered on 5/24/10, 6:03 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Criminal Law questions and answers in New York