Legal Question in Investment Law in New York

Sibling borrow money to invest in the bond market under false information

2 yrs ago 5 of my siblings (1 from WA, 1 from NJ & 3 from NY) gave over $250K (via checks & wire trfs) to 2 other siblings (both from NY) to invest in the bond market. The 2 siblings were day trading, are not licensed to trade & do not have property other than bank accounts. We are all over 18. There was no paperwork. All discussions & reporting of activities were done verbally due to trust. We recently discovered 90% of the funds were loss due to the 9/11 attack. The 2 siblings kept this fact from us in hopes of rebuilding the a/c back to its pre 9/11 bal ($1.2 million). Post 9/11, the 2 siblings asked the other 5 siblings to invest more money as their original funds had grown more than 5 times in earnings. Due to this info, an add'l $80K was given to invest. At 6/28/02 $135K was left in the a/c. The 2 siblings have decided to cutoff all contact with everyone. The 5 siblings would like to get an injunction for the existing account, freeze the assets of the 2 siblings to recoup their funds and pursue recourse action but have no documentation. Since the add'l $80K was never transferred to the brokerage a/c, we suspect the existence of other accounts. We have stmts from 8/2001 - 6/2002. The a/c is in the 2 siblings name.


Asked on 8/21/02, 10:12 pm

2 Answers from Attorneys

Michael Paradise Law Offices of Michael S. Paradise

Re: Sibling borrow money to invest in the bond market under false information

I am sorry to hear about your situation. If you have account documentation and proof that you and your co-siblings transferred funds to your investor siblings, then it might be enough to proceed for an injunction and asset freeze as you described. However, without a complete review of the documents and more background information, it is not possible (nor would it serve your interests), to render a legal opinion on the questions you have asked. There are other legal methods of attacking this issue which you might be interested in using.

One thing you have to be concerned about is the cost of litigation.

If I can be of any further help, please do not hesitate to contact me.

Read more
Answered on 8/22/02, 7:00 am
Jeffrey S. Eisenberg Jeffrey S. Eisenberg, Attorney at Law

Re: Sibling borrow money to invest in the bond market under false information

Your problem is extremely complicated due to the need to prove many factors in order to get an injunction, among other things. Initially, you need to prove that the transfer of money was not a gift or loan or for some other reason, and I suspect there is nothing in writing to this effect. (The memo on checks or letters after the fact can be useful). You do have some strength in numbers in that 5 individuals can state what their intentions were in giving such a great deal of money to their 2 siblings. Also, the timing of the investments may show where the money went and from what sources. However, the fact that the accounts are not in any of your names is something you need to overcome.

Ultimately, you will have to convince a judge that not only would a freeze on accounts be necessary to prevent further losses or the withdrawal of the remaining funds from these accounts, but that there is a strong likelihood that you can and will win the case. You probably have to post a bond if you are granted the injunction (you will need collateral for a surety company to consider granting you an injunction bond. You certainly will have to explain why you did not act more quickly to obtain the extrordinary relief you are now requesting from the court. Concealment of the true facts and retaining an attorney experienced in these matters should excuse whatever delay there may have been in commencing the law suit.

The fact that no one is licensed may be used to gain assistance from governmental agencies and/or the U.S. Attorney's office or District Attorney. All of this is quite complex, expensive and time consuming, not only for the lawyers involved, but for you and the other 4 who suffered the losses. You should act without delay to try to recover whatever may be left in the accounts in question, and to enforce your rights if you will have any chance of recovery.

In any event, I hope this is at least of some help in deciding what you will do next.

Read more
Answered on 8/22/02, 12:19 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Investment Law questions and answers in New York