Legal Question in Employment Law in New York

Unfair Firing

I am a chef and started a new job a week ago. My employer told me that I would become the head chef as soon as they told a current employee (who was not fulfilling his job requirements)that he had 2 weeks to find another job. I was told not to let anyone know that I would be taking over and to just assume the role of assistant chef for now. My employer was supposed to talk with the other employee today but instead told me that the other employee had ''stepped up to the plate'' and was now fulfilling his duties. Since I was the new hire and making more money they would have to let me go and would pay me for the rest of this week. He did not indicate that it had anything to do with job performance. In fact 2 days ago he assured me that I was doing a good job and would be taking over this weekend. I turned down other opportunities to take this job and want to know if their is any legal recourse that I could take.


Asked on 8/01/02, 11:35 pm

4 Answers from Attorneys

Harold M. Weiner Coles & Weiner, P.C.

Re: Unfair Firing

Did you have to relocate? Did you incur any expenses like selling a house and buying another one? You could charge him with the expenses incurred. But if it was in the same town, well... there is little you can do in an employment at will state like New York. That is why people should get written employment contracts when leaving a good job or turning down other offers. I realize it is unusual in your field but if more head chefs asked for written contracts like baseball players they would not be struck out so often.

Read more
Answered on 8/03/02, 3:16 am
David Slater David P. Slater, Esq.

Re: Unfair Firing

Unless you have all this in writing you will never be able to prove it. Next time insist on a contract reviewed by an attorney.

Read more
Answered on 8/02/02, 9:50 am
Brendan Chao Brendan Chao - Attorney & Counselor at Law

Re: Unfair Firing

Did you and the employer discuss other terms of your employment at the restaurant, e.g. how long you would work for? I disagree with the posting regarding the necessity for the agreement to be in writing. Oral contracts are entered into all the time.

Read more
Answered on 8/02/02, 9:54 am
Thomas Luz Pearce & Luz LLP

Re: Unfair Firing

I've looked at the two previous postings, and actually agree with both. It's smart to get employment contracts in writing, but you can prove their existence without doing so.

What hasn't been discussed yet is the law, which, unfortunately, is against you.

You clearly had an employment contract. You showed up for work and they paid you. That's enough evidence to prove the existence of an agreement. The problem is that the contract was one of "at will" employment. It was not for a fixed duration or did not provide that you could only be terminated "for cause." Under these circumstances either party may terminate the arrangement at any time, for any or no reason.

As to any promises of future promotions, these are swallowed up by the "at will" rule. Unless you can prove that the employer deliberately induced you to take employment by making promises they never intended to keep (which is easy to believe but incredibly difficult to prove), promises of a promotion are irrelevant to the analysis.

I'm sorry for your circumstances. Our economy depends on the free flow of labor and services, and the rules I outlined above are designed for that purpose. If it's any consolation, the "at will" rule cuts both ways. For every chef who's fired after two weeks, there's a chef who walks off the job after two weeks, leaving the restaurant in the lurch.

Regards,

Tom

Read more
Answered on 8/02/02, 10:26 am


Related Questions & Answers

More Labor and Employment Law questions and answers in New York