Legal Question in Wills and Trusts in New York

Family Owns Land Grant to Manhattan Island

Willed to the 7th generation - My grandmother by her/our Dutch ancestors was the ''Manhattan Island'' who they the Dutch bought the Island from the Indians. My grandmother who is deceased had at the time in the 1920's went to court to gain her rightful ownership and the lawyers, as I'm told were shot down on the court steps back then so the whole issue was droped for fear of being killed. Her children, my father and aunt who are alive today, but up there in their years know the exact story. I know it all sounds crazy but it's true. My question is would it ever be possible to reserect the paperwork and go after a monitary amount for what had been wrongfully taken? I would at the very least like to track down the land grant and will to my grandmother.


Asked on 5/01/02, 11:21 pm

3 Answers from Attorneys

Victor Hobbs Victor E. Hobbs

Re: Family Owns Land Grant to Manhattan Island

If there was a killing on the court house steps there's newspaper articles on the killing. There may also be a record in the court house concerning a claim or lawsuit filed. In any case you should be able to research this information, and don't forget to research the genealogy to trace your family tree.

Read more
Answered on 5/03/02, 12:34 am
Karen J. Segel Law Offices Of Karen J. Segel

Re: Family Owns Land Grant to Manhattan Island

Your facts are not set forth clearly. When you

say "willed to the 7th generation" does this mean

your ancestor did so just like that? Or did your

ancestor will it to his child, who willed it to

to his child, etc., etc., for seven times? If the

former, the devise would be illegal under the "rule

against perpetuities", as basically one can only

devise to some life in being plus 21 years.

At any rate, there should be newspaper articles,

and other ways to research this.

But you should be finding a New York lawyer, as

that is where the land is located.

Read more
Answered on 5/19/02, 11:21 am
Amy L. Finch, 845-362-0387 Amy L. Finch, Attorney and Counselor at Law

Re: Family Owns Land Grant to Manhattan Island

I'm not sure that I understand the entire situation, but I think I understand one part. You say the property was willed to the "7th generation." This is not legal even if it was done. Property can only be controlled for "lives in being plus 21 years." If your ancestors 7 generations ago willed the property, it would not be legal to keep it in the family through that one will until now.

Read more
Answered on 5/02/02, 12:06 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Probate, Trusts, Wills & Estates questions and answers in New York