Legal Question in Legal Ethics in North Carolina

Time limits if it took a long time to discover the mistake

Had a pain management box put into my back several years ago. It was suppose to stay in a few years but surfaced. The doctor removed it. There was severe back pain and had a MRI done and it was discovered that the wires and plug in devices were left inside. Muscles and tissues had covered them so they can not be removed. When this was discovered the statue of limitations had ran out. Been to several lawyers but they said they couldn't do anything because of the limitations law. It is hard for me to believe that because I didn't know why the pain was so bad until I had the MRI done that the statue of limitations would not play a role in this. Is there a law that will help me.


Asked on 5/03/04, 9:43 pm

1 Answer from Attorneys

John Kirby Law Offices of John M. Kirby

Re: Time limits if it took a long time to discover the mistake

Some of the statute of limitations rules are quite harsh. For medical malpractice, there is generally a three year statute of limitations (running from the discovery of the problem) and a four year statute of repose (running from the doctor's last act); you must meet both of these to prevail. There are a couple of "exceptions," which are generally difficult to meet. If the doctor concealed the malpractice, you might be able to avoid the statute of limitations (or repose). Also, if there was a "continuing course of treatment," then you might be able to effectively extend the statute of limitations. You can run a Google search on North Carolina General Statute 1-15(c) to get the language from the statute, and you can search the free online statute database(s). I will also note the following provision in the statute, "Provided further, that where damages are sought by reason of a foreign object, which has no therapeutic or diagnostic purpose or effect, having been left in the body, a person seeking damages for malpractice may commence an action therefor within one year after discovery thereof as hereinabove provided, but in no event may the action be commenced more than 10 years from the last act of the defendant giving rise to the cause of action." This was enacted to apply where, for example, the doctor left scissors or a sponge in the patient; I do not know whether this provision applies to your case. (I wonder if what you had was a spinal cord stimulator.) It sounds as if you have already consulted several lawyers, but of course you may want to continue to seek professional guidance here.

Read more
Answered on 5/03/04, 10:26 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Legal Ethics & Professional Responsibility questions and answers in North Carolina