Legal Question in Credit and Debt Law in Pennsylvania

I was involved in an auto accident where the police called an ambulance. I told the police that I was fine and did not need paramedic attention but they said I need to talk to the paramedics. I told them that I was fine and did not need there service. They then asked me if I need a ride and I said no. They then told me that I needed to sign a form that said I refused a ride and that was all the form was for.

I later received a letter with a charge of $150.00 from the Medic One service. In this letter they included the form that I signed. In the fine print it says that they have to ask me if I need transport but they do not have to tell me that I am being charged for evaluation and I am responsible for this charge.

I do not understand how I can be charged for something that I verbally refused. I had a hearing with the local magistrate and was found liable. They said I can appeal to common please court. Do I have a case to appeal this?


Asked on 3/25/11, 8:49 am

1 Answer from Attorneys
Rachel Hunter

I don't think it matters whether you said you were okay or not Police are not doctors and people can be injured and not fully realize the extent of their injuries, particularly after a car accident as things can start hurting after the accident. The police have to call the paramedics and the paramedics still have to evaluate you.

You could appeal, but you usually only have 30 days to appeal from the time that the magistrate ruled on the case. And it will cost money to appeal, which is money you could apply towards the medic bill. You can try to settle for less - I do not know if this is a private or governmental ambulance company. However, iIf the form says that you are responsible, then pay the charges.

Read more
Answered on 3/25/11, 11:32 am


Related Questions & Answers

More Credit, Debt and Collections Law questions and answers in Pennsylvania