Legal Question in Wills and Trusts in Pennsylvania

contesting distribution from trust in a will

My mother died on 08/05/2003. Her will specifies that my share of the estate be given out in annual payments of $10,000 until my death or until the trust is exhausted. I believe that the trust officer unduly influenced her so as to retain as much income from the trust as possible, and I don't believe that my dad, who died in 1979, would have wanted her to distribute this money over such a long period of time. The will reads in stirpes, so I cannot give my spouse or stepchildren anything from this trust if I die first. Can I contest this distribution and get a lump sum?


Asked on 8/02/04, 3:48 pm

2 Answers from Attorneys

Jonathon Moseley Jonathon A. Moseley

Re: contesting distribution from trust in a will

First, I'm not sure from your question in which State your mother died. I am assuming it is Virginia, so that Virginia law applies, but if it is not, then you need advice from a PA lawyer. Second, you raise a lot of good questions, although I think you base the questions on some misunderstandings of the will (or we don't have the information we need here). In other words, you raise good questions but, I think, for the wrong reasons from the will. For example, "per stirpes" should NOT necessarily means what you suggest. There could be some other part of the will that affects your spouse and stepchildren, but "per stirpes" by itself would have no effect on this one way or the other. In terms of the validity of the will saying that you should get $10,000 per year, if that is clearly what the will says, it would be very hard to overturn that. I think you would be better off exploring "factoring" or advances on the annual payments. I know of a company for doing that if you want to contact me. That is, a financial company would "buy" your right to receive future payments, assuming they are satisfied that the trust is good for the money. You would get the cash now. Since they won't know how long you will live, they would probably do it for only a few years into the future.

Read more
Answered on 8/03/04, 12:23 pm
James Apple Apple and Apple, P.C.

Re: contesting distribution from trust in a will

You can contest the validity of a Will, or any trust created by the Will, if there was undue influence used by this trust officer. Although you could file the papers yourself, I would not recommend it. Due to the complexities of a Will contest, an attorney should be used to fight this issue in Court. Please contact me at the address or numbers listed below if we can be of any further assistance.

Read more
Answered on 8/02/04, 4:04 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Probate, Trusts, Wills & Estates questions and answers in Pennsylvania