Legal Question in Civil Litigation in Puerto Rico

DNA-Test

I am currently in court because an alleged sibling is claiming to be my sister. She has no birth certificate, and supposedly my father -- who is now deceased -- never recognized her. Now, for DNA to be done, does she need to be tested with samples of my father's hair, etc., or would my blood suffice to prove her legitimacy? I would appreciate any information or suggestions that you can provide.


Asked on 3/30/01, 4:11 pm

1 Answer from Attorneys

Re: DNA-Test

My understanding of genetics and DNA is that

a comparison of yours and your alleged

sisters will not answer the question as to

whether she really is your sister. Her

mother, your father, and her blood (dna)

must all be tested and compared for this

comparison to be made

A more interesting question is why you are

in Court? If this is a Surrogate's

matter, and she is intervening because

she claims to be an heir, then she has

the burden of proving she is the child. If

this is a matter of her being named in a Will

as an heir and being listed as a daughter,

the designation of daughter is descriptive

not binding, and she would still inherit

whether she is or is not your sister.

Read more
Answered on 6/04/01, 6:40 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More General Civil Litigation questions and answers in Puerto Rico