Legal Question in Civil Litigation in Virginia

Rental Agreement

I recently rented a horse pasture for 2 of my horses. The person I rented from stated prior to signing the agreement that his horses were friendly. The agreement states that he will not be responsible for injuries to my horse. I have not yet been there a month and he is now saying I have to pay an additional $50 per horse. In addition, one of his horses attacked one of my horses resulting in cuts that will leave scars. I am now in the process of moving my horses since I refuse to pay the increase since I did not agree to it. Can I do anything?


Asked on 12/14/07, 5:41 pm

3 Answers from Attorneys

Ruth Emily Kochard Ruth Emily Kochard, Counselor at Law

Re: Rental Agreement

Your rights under this agreement would be defined by its terms. Unless it stated otherwise the lessor will be entitled to raise the rent/board as he wants. With respect to the friendliness of the horses, the boarder will typically bear the risk of injuries to his/her own horse. While potentially this risk was switched by his statement that his horses were "friendly" this is still a problem with respect to your proof that he breached the contract. There are horses that are "friendly" but that will nonetheless injure another horse in the field during a dominance dispute, or, while merely kicking up their heels for fun. In light of the struggle any claim against the lessor, I advise that you focus your energy on moving your horses to a more agreeable place (and sign a complete/useful contract prior to any boarding arrangement).

Read more
Answered on 12/15/07, 7:38 am
Ruth Emily Kochard Ruth Emily Kochard, Counselor at Law

Re: Rental Agreement

Your rights under this agreement would be defined by its terms. Unless it stated otherwise the lessor will be entitled to raise the rent/board as he wants. With respect to the friendliness of the horses, the boarder will typically bear the risk of injuries to his/her own horse. While potentially this risk was switched by his statement that his horses were "friendly" this is still a problem with respect to your proof that he breached the contract. There are horses that are "friendly" but that will nonetheless injure another horse in the field during a dominance dispute, or, while merely kicking up their heels for fun. In light of the struggle any claim against the lessor, I advise that you focus your energy on moving your horses to a more agreeable place (and sign a complete/useful contract prior to any boarding arrangement).

Read more
Answered on 12/15/07, 7:38 am
Ruth Emily Kochard Ruth Emily Kochard, Counselor at Law

Re: Rental Agreement

Your rights under this agreement would be defined by its terms. Unless it stated otherwise the lessor will be entitled to raise the rent/board as he wants. With respect to the friendliness of the horses, the boarder will typically bear the risk of injuries to his/her own horse. While potentially this risk was switched by his statement that his horses were "friendly" this is still a problem with respect to your proof that he breached the contract. There are horses that are "friendly" but that will nonetheless injure another horse in the field during a dominance dispute, or, while merely kicking up their heels for fun. In light of the struggle any claim against the lessor, I advise that you focus your energy on moving your horses to a more agreeable place (and sign a complete/useful contract prior to any boarding arrangement).

Read more
Answered on 12/15/07, 7:39 am


Related Questions & Answers

More General Civil Litigation questions and answers in Virginia