Legal Question in Business Law in California

Can someone tell me if this process is legal?

A supplier here in the states buys electronic components from China. The supplier informs the end user who is the manufacture of the end products that the parts may be suspect and need to be tested upon arrival. The end user tests the components and the parts pass. The supplier wires money to the source in China who shipped the parts. Does this release the supplier in the states from any legalities for this sale? My concern is that the end user who tests the parts upon arrival may not be doing a full range test that is done at the component factory. There is no way to know what sort of products these components will end up in. Thanks for your feedback.


Asked on 5/28/10, 9:02 am

2 Answers from Attorneys

It sounds legal. You don't describe any crime. But that doesn't really seem to be your issue.

What you really seem to be asking is if the supplier has adequately itself from any and all liability for the parts. Unfortunately you have not provided nearly enough information to even begin to render an opinion on that question. You need to retain an attorney to go over all the facts and terms of the purchase and sale transactions, including any documentation. Then you probably should pay for another few hours of attorney time to go over and restructure your business practices and documents to make sure you don't face this kind of question again in the future with other parts.

Read more
Answered on 5/28/10, 12:24 pm
Bryan Whipple Bryan R. R. Whipple, Attorney at Law

The Uniform Commercial Code and related international laws generally present two or three hurdles for the supplier to meet. First, the buyer generally has the right, and the duty, to make an inspection of the goods upon arrival, to make sure they are the right merchandise, that there has been no damage in transit, the quantity is correct, and there are no obvious defects. This usually completes the purchase transaction - the goods are sold, title passes, payment is due, and the buyer can use or resell the goods.

However, the seller's responsibility doesn't end there. In most transactions, unless the contract provides otherwise, there is an implied warranty. In addition, in many transactions and in many industries, including the electronics industry, sales of goods carry express warranties that are either spelled out at length in the contract or adopted by reference to an industry standard. I've forgotten the industry standard in electronics - something like EIA or EMA - but you being in the trade may know of it.

Components which later on fail to meet either an implied warranty of fitness and suitability, or an express warranty, will probably result in future warranty claims from the dissatisfied buyer even if they passen an initial inspection and test. It's like having a contractor install a 30-year roof. Being watertight the first rainy season does not answer all the questions.

Read more
Answered on 5/28/10, 9:44 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Business Law questions and answers in California