Legal Question in Workers Comp in Illinois

I am a banker and was asked by my supervisor to go outside, climb a ladder, and replace letters on a sign approximately 6-7 ft. tall. I subsequently fell off the ladder, landing on my outstretched arm, dislocating my right shoulder. I had surgery on this shoulder approximately 15 years ago due to chronic dislocations, however have had no problems until this incident. My question is whether anyone thinks I need to retain an attorney in this matter considering my employer seems to be cooperating in paying for medical care up to this point. In addition, is it relevant that the task I was assigned to was out of the scope of duty usually assigned to my position?


Asked on 4/20/10, 8:38 pm

3 Answers from Attorneys

Betty Tsamis Tsamis Law Firm PC

You should absolutely contact a workers compensation attorney. The workers compensation system is highly complex and an employee needs an advocate. Although there is cooperation right now, you will come to a point of maximum medical improvement. At that point, you will get an impairment rating. The employer will want to see you with the lowest possible impairment rating. You will obviously want the highest rating. This is the point a settlement is made to compensate you for future medical costs, pain and suffering, etc. You will need an attorney who can request a second opinion if necessary and negotiate a settlement with the insurer.

Read more
Answered on 4/26/10, 5:16 am
Nima Taradji Taradji Law Offices

I am sorry to hear about your injuries.

Here is what happens. Most injured start believing that their employer and the insurance company are nice and are doing the right thing because they pay for the medical bills. Do not be fooled and do not put your guards down. They do so because the have to and because it the law. Here are what you are entitled to:

1- payment for all your medical care; 2- most of your wage loss; 3- temporary total disability.

The part where you will be given grief is when, and if, your doctor tells them you cannot go back to work and they send you to their own doctor and the company doctor tells them that you are fit to run a marathon. Or, when time comes to decide the percentage of your disability. Without an attorney, you stand no chance to have a reasonable discussion with an adjuster whose sole purpose is to short change you--and that he has received hours of training in how to do it most effectively. At this point, do not be fooled into thinking that anyone is on your side. Without an attorney, you will most likely be settling your case for a song.

With respect to your question, in my view, if a supervisor asked you to do something, he temporarily placed that which he asked you to do within the scope of your employment.

I hope this helps-

Read more
Answered on 4/26/10, 5:21 am
John Wunsch Law Offices John C. Wunsch, P.C.

Dear Sirs,

This is a compensable case since you were instructed to perform the work you were performing. It would be difficult for the employer to argue that this was not within your duties since you were told to perform the work that you were doing.

Should you wish to speak to a lawyer who has practiced for nearly thirty (30) years and has handled many such cases, please do not hesitate to call our office. (312) 977--9900.

Many thanks,

John C. Wunsch

Law Offices

JOHN C. WUNSCH, P.C.

[email protected]

Read more
Answered on 4/26/10, 6:44 am


Related Questions & Answers

More Workers' Compensation Law questions and answers in Illinois