Legal Question in Personal Injury in Michigan

Leg Injury during baseball

I have a question pertaining to my brother who was injured the other day during a softball game. He participates in an adult intramural softball league and was at another teams field which is owned by a bar that is located next to the field. During the game, my brother made an attempt to slide feet first into second base where unknowingly realized how bad of shape the in-field was. From my understanding he stated that it almost felt like a hardened clay with little pot holes which eventually cause his big toe to get pushed back towards his ankle and may have caused a tendon to tear. Currently he is in a cast with crutches and my question is if he can proceed with receiving damages for his medical costs or if the accident falls under the idea of a presumption of risk.


Asked on 7/26/06, 5:10 pm

1 Answer from Attorneys

Michael End End, Hierseman & Crain, LLC

Re: Leg Injury during baseball

You are posing a difficult question. The first issue that comes to mind is whether the owner of the baseball field is protected by the Recreational Use Statute, Wis. Stat. sec. 895.52. The statute provides that no owner of property used for recreational activities has a duty to keep the property safe for recreational activities, has no duty to inspect the property, and has no duty to give warning of an unsafe condition. An exception to the immunity provided by the statute is for organized sports activities sponsored by the owner of the property on which the activity takes place. Unless your brother's situation falls within that exception to the rule of immunity, he may be barred from recovery. Irrespective of the recreational use statute, your brother may have a difficult time recovering compensation because of his potential contributory negligence. If it were determined that your brother was more at fault in causing his injuries than the owner of the field, your brother would not be able to recover compensation for what happened. Irrespective of the negligence issues, the only way that the medical bills might be covered by the owner of the field would be if the owner had an insurance policy in effect at the time of the injury that contained a medical payments coverage that would pay medical bills to a certain limit for anyone injured on the property, irrespective of fault. There is a three-year statute of limitations for filing a case for personal injury in Wisconsin. If the recreational immunity statute does not apply and if your brother were determined to be less at fault than the owner of the field, your brother would have to file a case within three years of the date of his injury if he wished to pursue the claim against the owner of the field and/or his insurance company.

Read more
Answered on 7/26/06, 10:38 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Personal Injury Law and Tort Law questions and answers in Michigan