Can a police officer give a minor their Miranda rights without a legal guardian present?
3 Answers from Attorneys
Yes. Police only need give a Miranda rights advisory if (1) the person to be questioned is "in custody;" and (2) the police officer is asking questions. Both must be the case before a Miranda warning is required. This applies to minors, as well as adults. An adult can refuse to answer police questions. An adult can refuse to answer police questions also by asserting their 5th Amendment right to refuse to answer, and their 6th Amendment right to legal counsel first. A juvenile can do the same - but has an additional ground. A juvenile can also refuse to answer questions until a parent is present. Hopefully the parent will then help assert these rights to refuse questioning. Police are not required to advise the juvenile of their right to refuse questioning without a lawyer and a parent present. But if the juvenile knows this, they can assert these rights.
Hello. The general answer is 'yes', but more detail needs to be know in order to provide additional comment that is responsive to your personal issues and concerns. Turn to your attorney so she/he can assist you and advise you. Tricia Dwyer Esq at 612-296-9666 Tricia Dwyer Esq & Assoc PLLC
Yes. There is nothing that precludes an officer from questioning a child without the parentis being notified or present.
Related Questions & Answers
Hi, My boyfriend and I were on our way home from a gig last Friday night and got... Asked 11/20/13, 10:01 am in United States Minnesota Criminal Law
My house got raided due to my wife on probation the task force and police came in... Asked 11/19/13, 6:49 pm in United States Minnesota Criminal Law
I had been taking heroin for one month. I decided to quit voluntarily - no court... Asked 11/19/13, 7:14 am in United States Minnesota Criminal Law
I had two bars of soap that I had purchased at one of the thrift stores in town (... Asked 11/17/13, 7:54 pm in United States Minnesota Criminal Law
How long do i half to be off of paper to get my record expounged Asked 11/16/13, 8:40 am in United States Minnesota Criminal Law