Legal Question in Sexual Harassment in New York

Malicious Complaint Against a Supervisor

A woman i supervise has filed a complaints against me

for secual harrassment and harrassment. She knows

she will recieve an unsatisfactory evaluation from me at

the end of this year, and I believe that the complaints

are in retaliation. I have never made a sexua advance

toward her. When other staff members made sexual

jokes, she joined in. She never once made any

statement that she felt offended by anything anyone

said.

In addition, she has convinced another employee to

join in the complaint with her. This employee also

never stated that any comments made by me or any

other staff member offended her.

How can I defend myself against this?


Asked on 4/13/02, 7:19 am

1 Answer from Attorneys

Thomas Luz Pearce & Luz LLP

Re: Malicious Complaint Against a Supervisor

All you can do as a supervisor is to play it straight. Give her your honest evaluation, supported as best you can by specific instances that confirm your assessment.

Your company should not leave you out there alone on this. You should have legal representation in the event that the employee commences a legal action, and the Human Resources Department should be papering the file in preparation for what looks to be a preemptive strike by an unsatisfactory employee to save her job.

Human Resources should interview the colleagues with whom the complainant enjoyed those jokes, and attempt to identify those who might corroborate her story.

Sex harassment allegations can, as you know, be dangerous. Pretextual ones can usually be sniffed out and defeated by timely, diligent work.

Read more
Answered on 4/15/02, 8:22 am


Related Questions & Answers

More Sexual Harassment Law questions and answers in New York