how does lache apply to landlord tenant law inn the floowing. Tenant and landlord signed a lease that had a provision for the landlord to pay untitlites. The provision stated that if the utilties were more than $50 a month the tenant would pay the difference. The utilities were in the landlords name. Unfortunately neither the tenant nor the landlord realized that payment prvision was in the lease. When the tenant ended the lease after 3 years the landlord came upon the provision and asked the tenant to pay all the back months utilties which totaled more than $50. He refused so the landlord took the $1800 or so out of the tenants deposit to get himself reimbursed. Is the landlors on firm gorund? Does lache apply?
1 Answer from Attorneys
Laches is the equitable notion that even though a person might have a legal right to something, it would be unfair to allow him that item or dollar amount because too much time had passed and the other person had reasonably relied upon the lack of action to their detriment. It is not a hard and fast rule that it clearly applies or does not apply in the gray area between what is fairly obvious. Here, I would guess that three years is not an unreasonable time and their was no harm to you in the landlord's behavior.
Related Questions & Answers
MY LANDLORD TERMINATED MY MONTH TO MONTH, RAISING MY RENT WITHOUT NOTICE; she says... Asked 2/02/12, 8:29 am in United States California Landlord & Tenants
On 5/28/2010 I entered into a lease agreement for my current residence. Itís a town... Asked 2/01/12, 11:18 am in United States California Landlord & Tenants
I live in Novato CA. I have subleased a room in our home since my father passed... Asked 1/31/12, 4:22 pm in United States California Landlord & Tenants
Tenant is living in an RV and not paying the rent. How can I evict them> Asked 1/31/12, 12:39 pm in United States California Landlord & Tenants
Today 1/30/2012 i was asked to moved out of a room that i've been renting for the... Asked 1/30/12, 9:20 pm in United States California Landlord & Tenants