Legal Question in Criminal Law in India

subject

payment is issued by the way of bank cheque in the name of a minor and the cheque got bounced, due to accounts closed reason . Is it possible for the father and natural guardian of the minor to contest the case? Is it admissible by Indian Court which comes under Section 138 negotiable insturment act.


Asked on 7/28/05, 12:23 pm

2 Answers from Attorneys

roopesh sharma ROOPESH KR.SHARMA and ASSOCIATES

yes

yes it is possible to do so .and u have a sure shot at winning the case if u act within limitation.

Read more
Answered on 7/28/05, 1:03 pm
Mahesh T. Pai M. A. T. Pai & Mahesh T. Pai

Re: subject

Your question raises an even more fundamntal issue:-

Since Minors are not capable of contracting, banks do not open accounts in minors' names. They do however allow parents / guardians to open accounts in minors names - that is a different matter altogether. In the latter situation, the minor gets to operate the account after attaining majority. So, the crucial question is - how was the minor able open a bank account and more importantly, how was a minor issued a cheque book?

This situation suggests either (a) serious lapse on part of the bank or (b) serious misrepresentation by the minor or his guardians to the bank as well as payee of the cheque.

In either case , proceedings for fraud and cheating may lie against the guardian. if it can be shown than (s)he connived in helping the minor open a bank account and get a cheque book.

Conviction for offence under Section 138 of NI act has been already upheld in cases where the account was closed before presentation fo the cheque. So, the fact that th account was closed only suggests that the minor or people acting on his behalf were intenting to cheat / defraud the payee from the outset. This factor only aggravates the offence.

Read more
Answered on 7/28/05, 8:41 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Criminal Law questions and answers in India