Legal Question in Employment Law in Massachusetts

Laid off 9 days prior to Maternity Leave

I have filed a complaint against my former employer with the MCAD for maternity leave discrimination and sexual discrimination. They have responded stating that I was a poor performer and that was why I was laid off. My feeling was that I was ''set-up'' to be laid off starting around the time I informed my manager that I would be taking maternity leave. For 4 years I was a strong performer in the top percentiles. I received a 20% salary increase and a bonus for being a ''good performer'' and then a few months later, I suddenly became a ''poor performer''. This coincided with my announcement that I was pregnant. I think that they would have laid me off eventually, however they did so 9 days before my scheduled maternity leave. I attempted to find another position in the company, however there were no positions in my area at the time. I was also informed by my supervisor that ''it would be very difficult to find a position considering I was only 9 days from maternity leave''. I understand that they have built up quite a case stating that I was a poor performer. I am wondering if I should continue to pursue this issue.


Asked on 12/03/02, 10:32 am

3 Answers from Attorneys

Thomas Murphy Law Office of Thomas Murphy

Re: Laid off 9 days prior to Maternity Leave

Yes, you should pursue this. Employers often use the tactic of claiming that an employee was performing poorly as a way to cover up their discriminatory actions. The burden is on you to prove that the reason the employer gave to the MCAD for its decision to terminate you is actually a "pretext" for their true motive - gender and pregnancy discrimination. It sounds to me like you have some ammunition in that respect - your prior performance. A reasonable person looking at the circumstances of your case - i.e. that your were a strong performer right up until the time that you informed them of your pregnancy, when you suddenly became a "poor" performer - might very well decide that there is a correlation between those two latter events. You may want to consider hiring a lawyer, because that would allow you to conduct discovery prior to going to a Public Hearing in the case. During discovery, you could make the employer answer written questions under oath, ask them to give you documents which may help you prove your case, and depose some of the key people within the company.

Read more
Answered on 12/03/02, 11:24 am
Nance Lyons Law Office of Nance Lyons

Re: Laid off 9 days prior to Maternity Leave

The response of your employer is the same response that every employer gives when someone claims they violated the discrimination laws. Hang in there.

Read more
Answered on 12/03/02, 5:10 pm
henry lebensbaum Law Offices of Henry Lebensbaum (978-749-3606)

Re: Laid off 9 days prior to Maternity Leave

I agree with the others:

There is a strategic interplpay in litigation, and what is required is an understanding of the situation, and what the legal standards which are necessary. You need to be careful about responding to the employer's position statement to make your initial case.

Then, if you pass, there will be an opportunity to discovery information and documents from the employer,

If you believe in your position, DO NOT GIVE UP!!!

Read more
Answered on 12/04/02, 12:11 am


Related Questions & Answers

More Labor and Employment Law questions and answers in Massachusetts