Can Contractor REFUSE to Pay Professional Services Sub-contractor's Invoice of about $100,000 in Maryland if Invoice Submitted for Payment 12 months late per Contract but still within its 3 ys of Statute of Limitations?
Q1. What is the legal basis for such Refusal to Pay, if any?
Q2. A cause of action for breach of contract typically accrues at the time of the breach. Kumar v. Dhanda, 426 Md. 185, 195 (2012), or date Invoice was submitted even though it was late, correct?
Q3. Can one reference an Unreported caselaw, for this matter, e.g. MORRIS & RITCHIE ASSOCIATES, INC. v. H&H ROCK, LLC, No. 1824, September Term, 2016. Unreported per Md. Rule 1-104?
1 Answer from Attorneys
"Can" someone refuse to pay an invoice they received a year late? Yes. People can and do refuse to pay other people all the time. Whether the non-payment will stand up in court or not is another question which can't be answered without knowing more.
Presumably the question tries to understand whether someone has a legally defensible reason for not paying an invoice (or whether the person who wants to get paid has a good faith basis for filing a lawsuit to get paid). Those kinds of questions depend heavily on the facts of a specific case, will almost certainly require analysis of the particular contract, invoices and services performed. Basically the question can't be realistically answered without a private consultation with an attorney.
Can unreported opinions be referenced in a court proceeding? Usually no. Typically a lawsuit doesn't reference legal opinions in the Complaint or Answer at all. Instead, the pleadings are based on the cause of action per established case law without reference to prior court cases. Legal arguments with supporting cases often arise at summary judgment or in the context of a motion to dismiss or on appeal.
You're highly encouraged to sit down with an attorney to answer any questions you may have about a particular contract/debt. This online response tries to give very general legal information and isn't a substitute for legal advice on the specifics of your situation.
Related Questions & Answers
Can I serve someone who stole 40k from my Business 10 years ago since I’m just... Asked 5/27/20, 8:07 am in United States Maryland Business Law
Can i operate multiple eCommerce under the umbrella of a business consulting firm? i... Asked 9/18/19, 12:00 pm in United States Maryland Business Law
My wife and I are looking for an attorney in Baltimore, Maryland to help us purchase... Asked 6/26/19, 11:14 am in United States Maryland Business Law
Mother in law receives a monthly payment from a person that bought a family business... Asked 4/06/19, 10:48 am in United States Maryland Business Law