Legal Question in Legal Malpractice in New Jersey

Lawyer told me to lie on deposition.

What recourse do you have when your lawyer tells you to lie to an insurance company at an accident deposition and then gives the insurance company proof that you lied?

Asked on 1/02/02, 10:55 pm

1 Answer from Attorneys


Re: Lawyer told me to lie on deposition.

Dear Lawguru Participant:

Concerning your 1/2/02 posting, based upon the facts you have described, in New Jersey, your deposition testimony may be covered by N.J. Statute 2C:28-1 [Perjury], Subsection (d), which provides:

d. Retraction. It is an affirmative defense under this section that the actor retracted the falsification in the course of the proceeding or matter in which it was made prior to the termination of the proceeding or matter without having caused irreparable harm to any party.

You and your attorney together, in advance, should probably have considered the best way of utilizing the provisions set forth in subsection (d) concerning a retraction. (If the lawyer who assisted you at the time of your deposition and you disagree as to the substance of the retraction, then you should probably take immediate steps to consult with an independent attorney.)

Your posting is presented under a category entitled "Legal Malpractice Law." I would need to know more facts to determine whether there is any possible cause of action for "legal malpractice" on your behalf against the attorney who assisted you in your deposition.

Wish best wishes to you and yours for the New Year, I hope this information is beneficial to you.

Dave Lubin


You are cautioned that, in the absence of a fully executed client agreement with the sender as your retained attorney, you should not consider

information provided by the Internet to constitute legal advice or opinion regarding any specific issue or factual circumstance.

If you have received this communication in error, please notify the sender by reply transmission,

and kindly delete the message without copying or disclosing it.

If this communication is incomplete or illegible, if any attachment contains a macro or a format

which may be inconsistent with your system, if you require a hard copy of any transmitted

materials, if you desire further information, or if your name and address should be deleted from

the mailing list of the sender, kindly reply by e-mail to this message.

Thanks. [revised on January 3, 2002 (11:15 am)]

[end of text]

Read more
Answered on 1/03/02, 11:36 am

Related Questions & Answers

More Legal Malpractice Law questions and answers in New Jersey