Hi I am taking a class in basic criminal law and i was asked this question
A community has enacted a law requiring residents to separate their garbage into recyclables and non-recyclables. The recyclable items are placed in plastic containers marked "Property of the City of Ecology." The city collects the contents of the containers and sells it to a recycling facility, boosting the city budget by several hundred thousand dollars per year. Joe, a homeless man, makes the rounds on garbage day and selects metal cans from the recycling bins, which he crushes and sells to a recycling facility. He is arrested and charged with theft of city property. You have been asked to analyze the case on behalf of the Public Defender representing Joe.
What is Joe's best defense to the theft charges?
I was wondering if someone can point me in too the right direction to answer this question.
1 Answer from Attorneys
Garbage is abandoned property so no one owns it
Related Questions & Answers
Can a person be charged if they overdose on an illegal drug? Asked 6/26/13, 10:04 am in United States New Hampshire Criminal Law
When someone is being booked for a misdemeanor is he allowed to have his spouse with... Asked 6/09/13, 6:56 am in United States New Hampshire Criminal Law
How do I file perjury charges in New Hampshire? I have the transcript of the court... Asked 4/03/13, 8:15 am in United States New Hampshire Criminal Law
Do i have to testify agianst someone if i don't want to Asked 2/01/13, 2:05 pm in United States New Hampshire Criminal Law
Argument turned into fight. he threw first punch that landed and knocked my glasses... Asked 12/20/12, 5:33 pm in United States New Hampshire Criminal Law