Legal Question in Personal Injury in Massachusetts

My parents were involved in an accident approx. a year ago, the person that hit him crossed lanes and hit the passenger side of their vehicle head-on. The police wrote him up on the scene for marked lanes violation. My mother was injured and has about 20k in med. bills. Now my parents att. are stating if they go to court and not settle for the ins. company settlement of 50k there is an excellant chance the person that hit him will clame a seizure., then the whole case gets tossed. There were no claims of this at the scene and the ER has no proof that a seizure accured? There also is nothing in his med. record from the past to support this either? To further complicate things, my parents lawyer also states the person that hit them is a nice guy, with a clean record which makes it hard to pursue with a jury!? Is this scenario common?

Thanks ahead of time.


Asked on 7/24/11, 5:21 pm

3 Answers from Attorneys

Not enough information to evaluate or second guess attorney's advice. Need to have a lot more information.

Read more
Answered on 7/24/11, 8:22 pm
John Chistolini Chistolini & Desimone Law Firm, PC

I would need to have more information Please feel free to call us @ 617-984-0021 or visit our website www.counselatlaw.com

Read more
Answered on 7/24/11, 10:59 pm
J. Whitfield Larrabee J. Whitfield Larrabee

What you describe is an interesting scenario. It is not clear what your parents mean when they say the case could be "tossed." It is not likely based on the facts you describe that a judge would rule against your mother prior to trial. Of course, in any case that goes to trial, the jury might find for the defendant. The jury would have to consider the evidence of precisely what happened and decide whether or not to credit the defendant's claim that he had a seizure. They might consider how likely it was that he had a seizure when he had never had one before. They would need to consider what time of day the incident occurred, what the defendant said to the police immediately after the accident, and whether the defendant was examined by a physician after the accident and what were the findings of the physician.

Whether to accept a settlement offer in a case such as this might involve many factors such as: the amount of insurance availalbe to compensate the plaintiff's for their injuries, the type of injuries suffered and whether or not they are permanent, whether the defendant was charged with any motor vehicle offenses and the outcome of those charges, etc.

Read more
Answered on 7/26/11, 1:41 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Personal Injury Law and Tort Law questions and answers in Massachusetts