My wife is having laparoscopic surgery to remove an ovarian cyst. The doctor we're using has a good reputation as does the hospital. However routine it may be, the doctor's paperwork involves signing a consent form that contains a clause releasing the doctor and hospital from "liability and responsibility due to any complications whatsoever that arise." Question 1 : Is that normal and should I be concerned? Question 2 : If something were to happen, is that release airtight or would we retain the right to sue them in case of legitimate malpractice ?
2 Answers from Attorneys
Although I am not sure the release is airtight, I would recommend you not sign such a release. If necessary, go someplace else to have it done. Alternatively, state in release that a complication is not "negligence."
Prospective negligence cannot be waived. However, fo the all the things you are warned about that can go wrong, you likely could not pursue a claim involving any of them that occurred in the ordinary manner of handling such a procedure. You likely would not have any of those claims without the release. Bad results are not negligence and you could not pursue that either. I would not be so worried about the clause, which is likely unenforceable if some true malpractice occurs.
Related Questions & Answers
Do I have a case against a doctor & or a hospital? I had an apt set up by a Dr.... Asked 2/23/13, 12:42 pm in United States Florida Medical Malpractice Law
My mom was recently released from a nursing home with several prescriptions, which... Asked 2/18/13, 1:26 pm in United States Florida Medical Malpractice Law
I asked a lawyer here this question and got an answer but he hasn't responded to my... Asked 2/16/13, 7:14 am in United States Florida Medical Malpractice Law
Does a medical doctor need a current/active DEA number/registration in order to... Asked 2/15/13, 8:32 pm in United States Florida Medical Malpractice Law
So my question is, my aunt has been diagnosed 3 different times saying she has bone... Asked 2/15/13, 11:36 am in United States Florida Medical Malpractice Law